When did bitcoin first reach $10,000?
UTXOHub · Bitcoin's history
Bitcoin first passed $10,000 on 29 November 2017, at 01:45 UTC by CoinDesk's price index, ten times its price at the start of that year. The same day it reached $11,377, then fell below $9,300 as exchanges struggled with the crowds. It peaked near $20,000 three weeks later and spent most of the next year falling.
A year of rising prices
Bitcoin began 2017 by passing $1,000 on New Year's Day, CoinDesk reported, for the first time since the Mt. Gox years told in When did bitcoin first reach $1,000? It passed $2,000 in May and $3,000 in June, and early in September it went above $5,000, CoinDesk's Stan Higgins recorded at the end of the year.
Then came a scare from China, where much of the trading had happened. On 4 September Chinese authorities banned initial coin offerings, sales of new digital tokens to raise money for start-ups. Ten days later BTCChina, one of the country's biggest exchangesExchangeA business where people swap ordinary money for bitcoin and other coins. Coins left there are held by the exchange, which controls their keys., said it would stop all trading from 30 September, Reuters reported, and other Chinese exchanges soon followed. The price fell below $3,400 that day and past $3,000 the next.
The doubters were loud. On 12 September Jamie Dimon, the chief executive of JPMorgan Chase, the largest US bank, called bitcoin “a fraud”. “It's worse than tulip bulbs. It won't end well. Someone is going to get killed,” he said, CNBC reported, and he would fire any JPMorgan trader who traded it “in a second”, because “It's against our rules and they are stupid.”
Wall Street arrives
Within weeks the price had recovered, and a very different part of Wall Street was moving towards bitcoin. On 31 October CME Group, the world's largest futures exchange, said it would start trading bitcoin futures by the end of the year: contracts to buy or sell bitcoin at a set price on a later date, settled in dollars. “Given increasing client interest in the evolving cryptocurrency markets, we have decided to introduce a bitcoin futures contract,” its chief executive, Terry Duffy, said in its announcement. Futures would let big investors bet on bitcoin, for or against, without holding any.
Ordinary people were arriving too. Coinbase, the largest place in the US to buy bitcoin, had 13.3 million users by 26 November, more than the 10.6 million active brokerage accounts at Charles Schwab, the share-trading firm, PYMNTS reported, citing other reports. “Yes, Charles Schwab has a lot more assets in its accounts than Coinbase users,” the research firm Bespoke Investment Group noted, “but the idea that cryptocurrency's users are just a fringe part of the financial universe is not accurate.”
$10,000, and a wild first day
South Korea got there first: exchanges there traded bitcoin above $10,000 on 27 and 28 November. On CoinDesk's Bitcoin Price Index, which averages several large exchanges, it crossed at 01:45 UTC on 29 November, reaching $10,044, Omkar Godbole wrote. That was more than 900% up on the year, and 230% up on the low of about $3,000 in mid-September. All the bitcoin in existence was now worth close to $170 billion.
The day had only begun. Later that day the index touched $11,377, City AM reported. Then, in about ten minutes, it fell more than $1,000, and by 19:30 UTC it was at $9,290, Pete Rizzo reported for CoinDesk. GDAX, the trading exchange run by Coinbase, went offline, and its own price touched $8,593 just before it did. Coinbase said it was seeing “all-time high traffic”, and Bitstamp and Bitfinex had trouble too, Fortune reported. By the next morning the price was back around $10,000.
The warnings came from central banks as well as bankers. “It's a very particular asset, it's a speculative asset by definition looking to the developments in its price. Investors are taking that risk of buying at such high prices,” Vítor Constâncio, the vice-president of the European Central Bank, said that Wednesday, Fortune reported.
The peak and the fall
The rise went on for less than three weeks. Cboe, a Chicago exchange, started trading bitcoin futures on 10 December, and CME a week later, on the evening of 17 December. That day CoinDesk's index reached $19,783.21, the high point of 2017, CoinDesk recorded. Within days the price had fallen by about 30%.
Four economists, three of them at the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, argued in May 2018 that the timing was no accident. Before futures, it was very hard to bet on bitcoin falling, so the price was set by people who expected it to rise. Futures let pessimists bet against it, which pushed the price down. The run-up and fall after futures arrived “does not appear to be a coincidence”, Galina Hale, Arvind Krishnamurthy, Marianna Kudlyak and Patrick Shultz wrote, though they added that they did “not pretend to be able to forecast bitcoin prices”.
The fall lasted most of a year. On 15 December 2018 CoinDesk's index touched $3,122, CoinDesk recorded later, about 84% below the peak. Bitcoin did not pass its 2017 high for three years; it went above $20,000 for the first time on 16 December 2020.
Was the rise real?
At the time the reasons seemed plain: new buyers arriving through apps like Coinbase, and the promise of futures bringing in big investors. A study by two finance researchers at the University of Texas, John Griffin and Amin Shams, offered another. They followed Tether, a stablecoinStablecoinA token designed to keep a steady value, usually one US dollar, which its issuer promises to buy back. It isn’t bitcoin, and it depends on that issuer.: a token meant to be worth one US dollar, which traders used to move money between exchanges. In the Journal of Finance in 2020 they reported that buying with Tether came after the price had fallen and pushed it up sharply, and that the flow came from “one entity”. The pattern was “most consistent with the supply-based hypothesis of unbacked digital money inflating cryptocurrency prices”, they wrote. Their first version, in 2018, put a number on it: hours with heavy Tether buying, fewer than 1% of the total, went with 50% of bitcoin's rise.
Tether rejected the study. “All Tether tokens are fully backed by reserves and are issued pursuant to market demand,” it said in 2019, Decrypt reported, calling the updated paper “a watered-down and embarrassing walk-back of its predecessor”. Part of that defence did not survive. In 2021 New York's attorney general, Letitia James, found that starting no later than mid-2017 Tether had at times had no reserves to match its tokens, and said its claim of full backing “was a lie”; Tether and its sister exchange, Bitfinex, paid $18.5 million in a settlement. That finding was about reserves, not about the price of bitcoin.
Other economists looked at the same months and found less. Richard Lyons, of the University of California, Berkeley, and Ganesh Viswanath-Natraj, of the University of Warwick, tested whether new Tether moved the price and found “no significant effect on the prices of Bitcoin and Ethereum”. They added that their results “do not discount the possibility that price manipulation can occur”, because totals across the market cannot show money sent to one particular wallet, which is what Griffin and Shams had traced. The question is still open. As with the rise to $1,000 in 2013, both stories can be partly true. You can see where the price went next on the price chart.
References
- CoinDesk (Pete Rizzo), “Bitcoin Price Tops $1,000 in First Day of 2017 Trading”, 1 January 2017.
- CoinDesk (Stan Higgins), “From $900 to $20,000: Bitcoin's Historic 2017 Price Run Revisited”, 29 December 2017.
- Fortune (Reuters), “Bitcoin Is Plummeting After an Exchange in China Said It Would Halt Trading”, 14 September 2017.
- CNBC (Fred Imbert), “JPMorgan CEO Jamie Dimon says bitcoin is a 'fraud' that will eventually blow up”, 12 September 2017.
- CME Group, via Mondo Visione, “CME Group Announces Launch Of Bitcoin Futures”, 31 October 2017.
- PYMNTS, “Cryptocurrency Platform Coinbase Exceeds Usership Of Charles Schwab”, 27 November 2017.
- CoinDesk (Omkar Godbole), “It's Official: Bitcoin's Price Makes History Passing $10k”, 29 November 2017.
- City AM, “What goes up… Bitcoin (BTC) loses steam after topping $11,000 and drops back under $10,000”, 29 November 2017.
- CoinDesk (Pete Rizzo), “Bitcoin Price Falls $1,000 in Minutes to Drop Below $10k”, 29 November 2017.
- Fortune, “Bitcoin's Price Swings Have Been Especially Crazy in the Last 24 Hours. Here's Why”, 30 November 2017.
- Cboe Global Markets, via Mondo Visione, “Cboe Plans December 10 Launch Of Bitcoin Futures Trading”, 4 December 2017.
- Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, Economic Letter 2018-12, “How Futures Trading Changed Bitcoin Prices (Hale, Krishnamurthy, Kudlyak and Shultz)”, 7 May 2018.
- CoinDesk (Omkar Godbole), “A Year After Bottoming Out at $3,100, Bitcoin Is Up 127%”, 16 December 2019.
- CoinDesk, “Bitcoin Tops $21K, Blowing Past $20K Record”, 16 December 2020.
- Journal of Finance, vol. 75, no. 4, pp. 1913–1964, “Is Bitcoin Really Untethered? (Griffin and Shams), abstract”, 2020.
- John M. Griffin and Amin Shams, working paper, “Is Bitcoin Really Un-Tethered?”, 13 June 2018.
- Decrypt (Rakesh Sharma), “Tether: Bitcoin price manipulation study embarrassingly 'flawed'”, 8 November 2019.
- New York State Attorney General, “Attorney General James Ends Virtual Currency Trading Platform Bitfinex's Illegal Activities in New York”, 23 February 2021.
- NBER Working Paper 27136 (Lyons and Viswanath-Natraj), “What Keeps Stablecoins Stable?”, May 2020.