When did Satoshi Nakamoto disappear?
UTXOHub · Bitcoin's history
Satoshi Nakamoto, Bitcoin's creator, posted on the Bitcoin forum for the last time on 12 December 2010, the day after warning that WikiLeaks had “kicked the hornet's nest” and the swarm was heading for Bitcoin. Satoshi went on writing privately to a few developers until April 2011, when the last emails widely accepted as Satoshi's said: “I've moved on to other things.”
The week WikiLeaks found Bitcoin
At the end of November 2010 WikiLeaks began publishing secret US diplomatic cables. Within days PayPal, Visa and MasterCard stopped handling donations to it, amid what the Associated Press called “intense U.S. government pressure”. Its supporters struck back by flooding the payment companies' websites with traffic until they failed, a denial-of-service attack. On 8 December a group calling itself Operation Payback said it had caused “severe technological problems” at MasterCard's website, the AP reported.
On the Bitcoin forumBitcointalkThe Bitcoin forum Satoshi Nakamoto opened in November 2009. Much of Bitcoin’s early history, from the pizza offer to Satoshi’s last post, happened there., some members saw a chance. In a thread about how WikiLeaks could take bitcoin, a user called RHorning wrote: “Basically, bring it on. Let's encourage Wikileaks to use Bitcoins and I'm willing to face any risk or fallout from that act.” Satoshi answered the next morning, 5 December: “No, don't ‘bring it on’. The project needs to grow gradually so the software can be strengthened along the way.” Then came a direct appeal: “I make this appeal to WikiLeaks not to try to use Bitcoin. Bitcoin is a small beta community in its infancy. You would not stand to get more than pocket change, and the heat you would bring would likely destroy us at this stage.”
The press made the connection anyway. In an article for PC World, Keir Thomas called Bitcoin “a decentralized virtual currency that could either be the best idea since they figured out how to slice bread, or just another hacker's daydream”. He added: “If Wikileaks had requested Bitcoins then they would have received their donations without a second thought.” A bitcoin was worth about 20 cents, he wrote. On 11 December a forum member posted the article, and others noted that the rush of new visitors had briefly taken the Bitcoin website down. Satoshi replied that evening, in the last of these messages: “It would have been nice to get this attention in any other context. WikiLeaks has kicked the hornet's nest, and the swarm is headed towards us.”
The last post
Earlier that same evening, Hal Finney, the cryptographer who had received the first bitcoin payment from Satoshi in 2009, praised Satoshi's code as “an impressive job” and “some powerful machinery”. Satoshi answered: “That means a lot coming from you, Hal. Thanks.”
The next day, 12 December 2010, at 18:22 UTC, Satoshi posted “Added some DoS limits, removed safe mode (0.3.19)”, announcing a new version of the software now called Bitcoin CoreBitcoin CoreThe most widely run Bitcoin software: a full node that checks every block and payment, with a wallet built in. It grew from Satoshi's first version.. “There's more work to do on DoS, but I'm doing a quick build of what I have so far in case it's needed, before venturing into more complex ideas,” it began. DoS, short for denial of service, means overloading a computer until it stops working, the same kind of attack that had just hit MasterCard. Satoshi was frank about how exposed Bitcoin still was: “As Gavin and I have said clearly before, the software is not at all resistant to DoS attack. This is one improvement, but there are still more ways to attack than I can count.” The post didn't say what made the build urgent.
The new limits stopped one computer flooding the network's nodesNodeA computer running Bitcoin software that checks every payment and block against the rules, and passes them on to others. with messages, and a switch, -limitfreerelay, let a node limit how many transactions without a fee it passed on. The other change removed “safe mode” alerts, a temporary measure from after the bug that briefly created about 184 billion bitcoin that August. In safe mode, a node stopped sending payments after it received a warning. Satoshi called the alerts better removed “for the sake of appearances”: “It was never intended as a long term feature.”
Only three replies followed. A user called ribuck argued that safe mode protected sites such as the Mt. Gox exchange, and asked for a switch to keep it. Another, davout, asked a question addressed to “@satoshi” about what counted as a longer invalid chain. Nobody answered. The forum records that Satoshi edited the post at 16:45 UTC the next day, and Satoshi's profile still gives that minute, 13 December 2010, as the account's last activity, after 575 posts. The Satoshi Nakamoto Institute, which archives them, lists nothing later on the forum.
Handing over to Gavin Andresen
A week later, on 19 December, Gavin Andresen, a programmer in Amherst, Massachusetts, who had been working on the code with Satoshi since mid-2010, wrote: “With Satoshi's blessing, and with great reluctance, I'm going to start doing more active project management for bitcoin.” He set up the project's home on GitHub, where it still is, and asked for help: “this is the first open source project of any size I've been involved with.”
Satoshi still answered some email. In April 2011 Mike Hearn, a developer who had been writing to Satoshi since 2009, asked whether Satoshi planned to rejoin “or is your plan to permanently step back from the limelight?” On 23 April Satoshi replied: “I've moved on to other things. It's in good hands with Gavin and everyone.”
Three days later Satoshi wrote to Andresen, who had been quoted in the press that month. “I wish you wouldn't keep talking about me as a mysterious shadowy figure,” the email began, and it ended: “I've moved on to other things and will probably be unavailable.” With it came the alert key, a secret that let its holder send a warning to every copy of the software. Andresen published the email in 2022, with his reply, which mentioned that he had been invited to speak at the CIA. He never heard from Satoshi again. On 27 April 2011 he told the forum, in a post called “Gavin will visit the CIA”: “I want to get this out in the open because it is the kind of thing that will generate conspiracy theories.” He would be paid a one-time fee of $3,000, he wrote, and he gave the talk in June.
Why did Satoshi leave?
Satoshi never said, beyond “I've moved on to other things”. Satoshi's own posts that December show one worry clearly: that the attention WikiLeaks brought “would likely destroy us at this stage”, while the software could still be knocked over in “more ways to attack than I can count”. Whether that worry was why Satoshi left, nobody outside can say.
Another explanation points to the CIA visit. “11 years ago today, a #Bitcoin developer decided to visit the CIA. Satoshi Nakamoto was never seen again,” Pete Rizzo, an editor at Bitcoin Magazine, posted in 2022. The dates count against it. Satoshi's last forum post came more than four months earlier, and Satoshi had told Hearn “I've moved on” three days before Andresen mentioned the invitation. CryptoSlate's Samuel Wan called the link “speculative at best”.
Who Satoshi was is a separate question, and still open. The people who have been named, and their answers, are on Satoshi Nakamoto's profile.
After the last post
WikiLeaks began asking for donations in bitcoin in June 2011, Nonprofit Quarterly reported, as the payment companies' blockade went on. In 2017 its founder, Julian Assange, thanked the US government and two senators for pushing Visa, MasterCard, PayPal and others “into erecting an illegal banking blockade against @WikiLeaks starting in 2010”, adding: “It caused us to invest in Bitcoin -- with > 50000% return.” Nobody outside WikiLeaks knows how much it held, The Register noted.
Only one later message is often taken as Satoshi's. In March 2014, within a day of Newsweek naming a Californian called Dorian Nakamoto as Bitcoin's creator, Satoshi's old account on the P2P Foundation website posted a single line: “I am not Dorian Nakamoto.” The Satoshi Nakamoto Institute, which archives it, warns that the account was taken over after an email hack that September, though there is no clear sign it had been by March.
The coins Satoshi is believed to have mined have stayed where they are. CoinDesk reported in July 2025 that the estimated 1.1 million bitcoin had “remained untouched since 2010”. Satoshi's first and best-known block is still there to look at: the genesis block.
References
- MPR News (Associated Press), “Hackers strike at MasterCard to support WikiLeaks”, 8 December 2010.
- Bitcoin Forum, “Wikileaks contact info?”, December 2010.
- Satoshi Nakamoto Institute, “Re: Wikileaks contact info? (09:08:08 UTC)”, 5 December 2010.
- PC World (Keir Thomas), via Computerwoche, “Could Wikileaks Scandal Lead to New Virtual Currency?”, 11 December 2010.
- Bitcoin Forum, “PC World Article on Bitcoin”, 11 December 2010.
- Satoshi Nakamoto Institute, “Re: PC World Article on Bitcoin (23:39:16 UTC)”, 11 December 2010.
- Satoshi Nakamoto Institute, “Re: minimalistic bitcoin client on D language? (22:07:04 UTC)”, 11 December 2010.
- Bitcoin Forum, “Added some DoS limits, removed safe mode (0.3.19)”, 12 December 2010.
- Bitcoin Forum, “View the profile of satoshi”.
- Satoshi Nakamoto Institute, “Satoshi Nakamoto's forum posts”.
- Bitcoin Forum (Gavin Andresen), “Development process straw-man”, 19 December 2010.
- Mike Hearn, “Holding coins in an unspendable state for a rolling time window (emails with Satoshi Nakamoto)”, 18–23 April 2011.
- Gavin Andresen's blog (archived), “Eleven years ago today…”, 26 April 2022.
- Bitcoin Forum (Gavin Andresen), “Gavin will visit the CIA”, 27 April 2011.
- CryptoSlate (Samuel Wan), “Was the CIA behind Bitcoin creator Satoshi Nakamoto's 'disappearance'?”, 29 April 2022.
- Nonprofit Quarterly (Ruth McCambridge), “Wikileaks on a Bitcoin-Raising Campaign”, 15 June 2011.
- The Register, “Assange thanks USA for forcing him to invest in booming Bitcoin”, 16 October 2017.
- Satoshi Nakamoto Institute, “"I am not Dorian Nakamoto" (P2P Foundation, 01:17 UTC)”, 7 March 2014.
- CoinDesk (Shaurya Malwa), “Bitcoin's Mysterious Creator Is Almost the World's 10th Richest Person”, 14 July 2025.